The brand new proposal for the same legal rights pact is actually refused
Thereon date, the us Senate ratified the fresh new Equivalent Nationality Treaty, and President Roosevelt finalized into the law brand new Dickstein-Copeland costs, to begin with written by the Alice Paul
The conference fixed it can easily maybe not ‘impose’ such as blanket ‘joining financial obligation … in place of curtailing the latest sovereign rights of the additional States’. 107 However, new delegations from four claims – Cuba, Ecuador, Paraguay and Uruguay – made a decision to indication brand new pact. 108
The brand new Equivalent Nationality Pact gotten far large assistance. Several places had announced which they do indication they before the appointment exposed. Anyway, Latin-american governments make it motion away from goodwill with the feminist grounds for free, since their legal assistance already generally enshrined the main off equal nationality. The us manage ultimately transform the direction and you may sign up him or her. Since the goal of government entities to not ever sign became societal studies in the starting days of the latest fulfilling, supporters of your own treaty climbed good vehement venture of protest. Really the only women’s organization you to offered the fresh new government within this phase was the new NLWV. While they advertised and campaigned getting separate citizenship, ‘the newest NLWV’s leadership was basically also sidetracked from the apparent textual parallels between your nationality pact as well as the … equal legal rights amendment to evaluate the fresh new merits of your own nationality treaty independently. [It] had to be arrested since it could serve as the new means to the … new abolition of all the laws and regulations predicated on sex’. 109
The brand new protest went past feminists and you can reformers, searching help regarding all the country’s drive. Indeed, the general feeling try not finalizing during the Montevideo was not a consistent extension of the You coverage on Hague; as an alternative, it actually was an excellent betrayal of the spirit of these prior to decision one took a mean ladies legal rights. 110 Beyond public stress, there had been other affairs you to definitely preferred reconsideration of the management. Not wanting to sign a pact which was very firmly supported by Latin american countries don’t fit with the new ‘a good neighbour’ plan to which Roosevelt had the full time. Also, the usa as well as had absolutely nothing to lose with respect to the new obligations; the brand new Wire Act, with its previous modifications, currently recommended full equality atlanta divorce attorneys aspect of home-based nationality rules. In spite of new objections of your State dept., Roosevelt taught the latest delegation to improve their status. To your erican countries, such as the United states, closed this new Equivalent Nationality Treaty. 111
This new NLWV remained separated within its reputation
The brand new NWP renowned the outcome of one’s Montevideo appointment since a good turning point in background. 112 Anna Kelton Wiley affirmed one Paul, Stevens and you will Scott had been among the ‘few mortals … considering the higher contentment of profit and their individual labors’ and you can deserving ‘brand new appreciation away from machines of people’. She together with indicated her own personal appreciation so you can Scott: ‘Our very own several frontrunners are peerless within this high success however, instead your own high knowledge, great empathy and higher personality that it experiences could not have taken place.’ 113 Scott, alternatively, place the financing toward equivalence events completely in other places because of the coining him or her the newest Stevens Treaties. 114 He launched their account of 
Montevideo meeting on American Record off Internationally Laws because of the examining those two data files and placing comments on their pros:
During the Montevideo there was centered good and you will lighting up precedent. For the finding equality by the around the globe contract, our Western girls, whether or not consciously or not, keeps provided to tomorrow rules away from regions their inescapable and you will lasting guidelines; and also the upcoming laws out of places can it not be the newest result of the fresh venture of enlightened men? 115
The latest triumph regarding Montevideo could well be finished on twenty four Will get 1934. 116 For the outcome of the enactment, all of the rules into the All of us nationality legislation applied similarly in order to girls and men.